Not sure about in your local area but I recommend that you take a look at http://www.chess.com/equipment/chess+clocks
Anyone know where to buy a cheap chess clock in NYC?

That doesn't really help. I just need it cheap, I don't care about the ratings. The two sites that sell those clocks are pretty expensive. That's not even considering the shipping.

Maybe try contacting the Village Chess Shop and see if they can direct you somewhere that has cheap chess clocks. Their selection seems to be $40 and up. Chess Forum appears to have some as cheap as $25. They are both located near Wahsington Square Park on Thompson St.
Has anyone seen a chess clock for a good price in New York City? It can be made of wood for all I care as long as it's cheap. Under $10 is what I'm looking for.