Chess Pieces: Wood vs Plastic

Sort:
Eyechess

The question was brought up by a newcomer if Plastic pieces were preferred over Wood sets.

Of course personal preference takes the call, but there are trends that are observable.

The vast majority of sets used in higher level Chess events are in wood.

The plastic sets you see pictured from more elite events are pretty much all from before the 1970’s.  Since then you will see wood sets.
When looking at sellers you will see more Wood set options than Plastic.  When most people talk of buying a nice set, it is usually Wood.

Wood pieces are more expensive than plastic ones.  The cheapest wood set starts at around $40 where the cheapest plastic set costs well under $10.  And the most expensive plastic set will not even come close to $100.  The better wood sets will get to over $600.  
Because of the lower cost you will see people using plastic sets in situations where the pieces might see more abusive handling.  If a plastic piece or pieces gets broken or lost, it does not cost near as much to replace.

Wood sets are usually desirable for slower games where they will not be beat up so much.

Of course you will find people that prefer Plastic no matter what.  And some will only play with Wood pieces.  For about  a 12 year period, I only used Wood sets.  And today I use plastic pieces less than 5% of the time.  There are some Wood set designs that work great for the faster time play.

m_connors
Eyechess wrote:

The question was brought up by a newcomer if Plastic pieces were preferred over Wood sets.

Of course personal preference takes the call, but there are trends that are observable.

The vast majority of sets used in higher level Chess events are in wood.

The plastic sets you see pictured from more elite events are pretty much all from before the 1970’s.  Since then you will see wood sets.
When looking at sellers you will see more Wood set options than Plastic.  When most people talk of buying a nice set, it is usually Wood.

Wood pieces are more expensive than plastic ones.  The cheapest wood set starts at around $40 where the cheapest plastic set costs well under $10.  And the most expensive plastic set will not even come close to $100.  The better wood sets will get to over $600.  
Because of the lower cost you will see people using plastic sets in situations where the pieces might see more abusive handling.  If a plastic piece or pieces gets broken or lost, it does not cost near as much to replace.

Wood sets are usually desirable for slower games where they will not be beat up so much.

Of course you will find people that prefer Plastic no matter what.  And some will only play with Wood pieces.  For about  a 12 year period, I only used Wood sets.  And today I use plastic pieces less than 5% of the time.  There are some Wood set designs that work great for the faster time play.

 

Whatever suits the occasion, I would say. I own an elaborate Wooden set more for decoration than anything else. It is set-up for the first 5 moves of a PIRC defence. I used to own an inexpensive plastic set for everyday use. Now I use a small metal (magnetic) set. I only play chess online now, so don't really need a chess set.  happy.png

lonewolf69ay

Thank you!!! Just the answer I was looking for...  Plastic for mild abuse and tournament play...  Wood pieces for a slow pace/relaxing game, more care and less abuse...   -  Gotcha!!  grin.png

 

RussBell
Eyechess wrote:

The better wood sets will get to over $600.  

 

This is the only statement that I would take exception to.  Obviously, "better"is a term fraught with subjectivity.  There are MANY excellent quality wood chess sets (pieces) that sell (retail) for much less than $600USD.

A couple of examples (here, from HoS)...

One of Eyechess' favorites...The Craftsman Series.....a very fine set...featuring a unique Knight design...

https://www.houseofstaunton.com/the-craftsman-series-luxury-chess-pieces3-75-king.html

and a set I like....the Capablanca Series...elegant.....with another iconic Knight design...

https://www.houseofstaunton.com/the-capablanca-series-luxury-pieces-4-king.html

zagryan

Playing with wooden pieces feels like wearing a fine timepiece such as a Rolex or Omega. Plastic on the other hand feels like wearing a G-Shock. Both gets their job done but they're for different occassion and do perfectly well, in my humble opinion.

RussBell

Mammoth ivory sets aside, or those made of exotic materials, or antiques, the majority of new sets that are priced over $600USD are those which have ornately carved knights, as this is where the most skilled carving craftsmanship comes to the fore.  The remaining pieces in these sets are in many instances indistinguishable, in terms of design or craftsmanship, from sets costing much less.  So if you wish to have a set with the most ornately carved knights, you will very likely have to pay a premium for it.

Eyechess

I was just pointing out that wood sets are more expensive than plastic sets.

I said the better wood sets will get to over $600.  This is only a range.  I have never spent more than $600 complete on any set of mine.  The vast majority of wood sets I own cost well under $200.  And my 2 favorite Staunton style sets cost me under $350.  Of course my Noj sets cost me between $418  for the first I bought in 2010 to $600 for the one, BCE set with stainless steel bases.

The point I was making is that Wood sets are pricier than plastic ones.  Even though I own more Chess sets than some people, I am a cheapo and pay the least amount I can for quality stuff.  In my opinion, like RussBell, I see no need to buy those more expensive sets with all that frilly detail.  But that’s just my personal preference.

Now that I think of it, the most I ever paid for a plastic set was $52.  And that was back in 1990 for a new Drueke Players set.

lonewolf69ay
I love this quote!!!!  IMHO - Perfect analogy!!!  happy.png  Timex/Casio vs. Rolex/Breightling/Omega...  !!! Bravo...
zagryan wrote:

Playing with wooden pieces feels like wearing a fine timepiece such as a Rolex or Omega. Plastic on the other hand feels like wearing a G-Shock. Both gets their job done but they're for different occassion and do perfectly well, in my humble opinion.

 

Gomer_Pyle

I much prefer using wood. I have an old wooden set that I've used for study and practice since the early 1980's. It takes abuse much better than plastic, which I think has a good chance of cracking if used in the same way. That set has now accumulated so much sentimental value that I bought a couple other wood sets to use instead. The problem is I have a hard time using the new sets the same way because they're too nice and new. I'm working on it, though. I have other wood sets that get treated very gently. Those are the "fine china" for more genteel study or play.

lonewolf69ay
Gomer_Pyle wrote:

I much prefer using wood. I have an old wooden set that I've used for study and practice since the early 1980's. It takes abuse much better than plastic, which I think has a good chance of cracking if used in the same way. That set has now accumulated so much sentimental value that I bought a couple other wood sets to use instead. The problem is I have a hard time using the new sets the same way because they're too nice and new. I'm working on it, though. I have other wood sets that get treated very gently. Those are the "fine china" for more genteel study or play.

 

I know *EXACTLY* what you mean, in my shopping cart, I have two (2) druke sets that I'm getting ready to pull the trigger on, this will be my 1st PLASTIC set because I love my HoS Professional wood set dearly and don't want to risk damaging the set any more...  Maybe I'll get another wood set as well...  

Help me!!!  I'm getting addicted...  LOL  happy.png 

Gomer_Pyle

If you don't mind a couple flaws you can get some good deals on the HOS Outlet page. I bought an ebonised Marshall set whose only flaw was a cracked extra queen to replace my old set for hard use and abuse. Then they put the rosewood Marshall set (no flaws) on clearance so I bought one of those. Now I only need...

Eyechess

Well, I always find myself going back to the wood sets and not using the plastic ones.

I have used the same HoS Liberty Series Rosewood set since early 2000 or so.  I remember Frank Camaratta telling me of this Pinney set reproduction he was coming out with.  He told me, more than once, that it would wear like iron.  And he’s right.  That set is more than durable.  And I keep going back to it for the wood experience.

rocket-Ry
Eyechess wrote:

The question was brought up by a newcomer if Plastic pieces were preferred over Wood sets.

Of course personal preference takes the call, but there are trends that are observable.

The vast majority of sets used in higher level Chess events are in wood.

The plastic sets you see pictured from more elite events are pretty much all from before the 1970’s.  Since then you will see wood sets.
When looking at sellers you will see more Wood set options than Plastic.  When most people talk of buying a nice set, it is usually Wood.

Wood pieces are more expensive than plastic ones.  The cheapest wood set starts at around $40 where the cheapest plastic set costs well under $10.  And the most expensive plastic set will not even come close to $100.  The better wood sets will get to over $600.  
Because of the lower cost you will see people using plastic sets in situations where the pieces might see more abusive handling.  If a plastic piece or pieces gets broken or lost, it does not cost near as much to replace.

Wood sets are usually desirable for slower games where they will not be beat up so much.

Of course you will find people that prefer Plastic no matter what.  And some will only play with Wood pieces.  For about  a 12 year period, I only used Wood sets.  And today I use plastic pieces less than 5% of the time.  There are some Wood set designs that work great for the faster time play.

 

 

lonewolf69ay
rocket-Ry wrote:
Eyechess wrote:

The question was brought up by a newcomer if Plastic pieces were preferred over Wood sets.

Of course personal preference takes the call, but there are trends that are observable.

The vast majority of sets used in higher level Chess events are in wood.

The plastic sets you see pictured from more elite events are pretty much all from before the 1970’s.  Since then you will see wood sets.
When looking at sellers you will see more Wood set options than Plastic.  When most people talk of buying a nice set, it is usually Wood.

Wood pieces are more expensive than plastic ones.  The cheapest wood set starts at around $40 where the cheapest plastic set costs well under $10.  And the most expensive plastic set will not even come close to $100.  The better wood sets will get to over $600.  
Because of the lower cost you will see people using plastic sets in situations where the pieces might see more abusive handling.  If a plastic piece or pieces gets broken or lost, it does not cost near as much to replace.

Wood sets are usually desirable for slower games where they will not be beat up so much.

Of course you will find people that prefer Plastic no matter what.  And some will only play with Wood pieces.  For about  a 12 year period, I only used Wood sets.  And today I use plastic pieces less than 5% of the time.  There are some Wood set designs that work great for the faster time play.

 

 

 

Thank you Rocket - well said because I am that "Newcomer" that originally asked the question in another thread.  Eyechess was kind enough to start another thread here and honestly *ALL* of the answers and posts from the community has been so helpful and insightful and *YOUR* post alone completely summarizes all of them and is my train of thought and also my state of mind for Plastic vs. Wood...    Since I don't do tournaments and only casually play with friends and family in a home setting at a casual/friendly/gentle game, I'll stick with the wood sets, I'll probably pick up at least one (1) set of plastic from Drueke (Bill) just to add to my growing collection...   

Thank you so *ALL* so much for the info, this *NEWBIE* is very happy to have joined this community, in the span of ONE week, I've learned quite a lot!!!

 

lonewolf69ay
sound67 wrote:

I enjoy taking full-size plastic sets with vinyl boards with me on holiday, rather than a smaller, but equally heavy wooden set - but at home I always play with wooden sets.

 

Ha!!!  Good one, when I travel, I'm the ***ONLY*** one that wants to play chess...  So lugging around a portable Vinyl/Plastic set hasn't quite worked out for me...  My "TRAVEL" set has been sitting in the corner collecting dust...  I found myself playing chess on iPad when on holidays...  happy.png happy.png 

 

RussBell
lonewolf69ay wrote:

, I'll probably pick up at least one (1) set of plastic from Drueke (Bill) just to add to my growing collection...   

LoneWolf -

Before purchasing, you might want to read this entire forum thread concerning Bill Drueke's current edition of his plastic set.....it doesn't exactly receive ringing endorsements....

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-equipment/drueke-47?page=1

 

lonewolf69ay
RussBell wrote:
lonewolf69ay wrote:

, I'll probably pick up at least one (1) set of plastic from Drueke (Bill) just to add to my growing collection...   

LoneWolf -

Before purchasing, you might want to read this entire forum thread concerning Bill Drueke's current edition of his plastic set.....it doesn't exactly receive ringing endorsements....

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-equipment/drueke-47?page=1

 

Thanks for pointing this out, Russ, great read through...  

zagryan
lonewolf69ay wrote:
I love this quote!!!!  IMHO - Perfect analogy!!!    Timex/Casio vs. Rolex/Breightling/Omega...  !!! Bravo...
zagryan wrote:

Playing with wooden pieces feels like wearing a fine timepiece such as a Rolex or Omega. Plastic on the other hand feels like wearing a G-Shock. Both gets their job done but they're for different occassion and do perfectly well, in my humble opinion.

 

Thank you for kind words. You nailed the brands.

BTW, I enjoy playing with both wood and plastic pieces. They serve different needs. I don't want to play with only nice fancy wooden pieces. Sometimes, playing with dirt cheap plastic pieces is comforting, not having to worry about getting chipped and cracks or even stolen while playing. 

lonewolf69ay
zagryan wrote:
lonewolf69ay wrote:
I love this quote!!!!  IMHO - Perfect analogy!!!    Timex/Casio vs. Rolex/Breightling/Omega...  !!! Bravo...
zagryan wrote:

Playing with wooden pieces feels like wearing a fine timepiece such as a Rolex or Omega. Plastic on the other hand feels like wearing a G-Shock. Both gets their job done but they're for different occassion and do perfectly well, in my humble opinion.

 

Thank you for kind words. You nailed the brands.

BTW, I enjoy playing with both wood and plastic pieces. They serve different needs. I don't want to play with only nice fancy wooden pieces. Sometimes, playing with dirt cheap plastic pieces is comforting, not having to worry about getting chipped and cracks or even stolen while playing. 

 

"...You nailed the brands..."

 

It helps that I actually OWN those mentioned watch brands and this is *EXACTLY* how I wear them...  Everyday vs. Special occasions...!!!  happy.png 

Chill-Bhronai

forget about wood or plastic, bone is the way to go when buying a chess set . .