CT-ART vs Chess informant anthology of chess combinations

Has anyone consumed both and can tell me

if these two works overlap or if one is better?

ct-art would be more convenient bc it has an iOS app 

the anthology may be more comprehensive?

thanks

I have the book which I believe is related to CT-ART: https://www.houseofstaunton.com/combinative-motifs.html. It appears to be out of stock but they have a "shop-worn" copy available: https://www.houseofstaunton.com/shopworn-combinative-motifs.html.

Yes the one by Blokh 

that is the content for CT-ART

do you know how it compares to the content of

Anthology Of Chess Combinations

by Aleksandar Matanović

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10415216-anthology-of-chess-combinations

Good

Thank you very much

ill get through CT-Art first before attempting AOCC

This is the best Make sure you get material for your level and above

Having done many thousands of both (book problems and tactics trainer problems), I can tell you without a doubt that book problems (i.e., problems hand-selected by a human) are always of higher quality/instructional value than tactics trainer problems. With that said, tactics trainer problems have their advantages of course (very convenient/numerous/etc.).

The tactics trainer here is a joke.

Chess t from real games meaning most just win material and are from games above 2100.CT-ART is perhaps the best trainer over time patterns will be learned if you work hard you will go far.

I belong to chess t and I have CT-ART (several products) it takes work

It’s been said already but yes books and apps have different pros and cons

i break these out into several categories

1. books
2. Apps sourced from books
3. filtered online sets
4. random online sets

books and apps sourced from books have the benefit of the material being hand selected. The author can order the puzzles by pattern which is great for learning.

apps sourced from books, like CT-Art, have the benefit of interactivity.

this is also a con, bc the user can make one move, get it right, then think more for the next move, etc. 

books forced you to calculate the whole variation first. Books I think are better for training calculation and visualization. Apps may be a smoother and less frustrating  learning experience

online tactics trainers are more random, and the quality depends on the games they’re sourced from. You can create your own sets of themes tactics with rating bands on chesstempo and now here but it’s still not quite the same as a book

i like all of the above but there’s nothing like finishing a book