I very slightly prefer the Staunton knight in the pictures (cf #10), but I clearly prefer the Jacques rook.
But all in all, frankly, I don't care much. I analyse almost only on travel magnetic boards where pieces are painted circles, so I did not get used to the luxury pieces enough to be able to tell.
I'd hate to see that knight on the left coming for my king. I'd be running to the queenside!!
LOL