What a lovely gift! I'd be touched to receive such a set.
There's been a couple excellent threads where members thoroughly ran the numbers:
https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-equipment/a-system-for-sizing-chess-pieces-and-boards-long
and
Some additional resources here https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-equipment/correct-ratio-chessmen-base-to-square-size
With a 2" square these the first thread would suggest a 1.53" king base and a 1.17" pawn base. The benchmarks of actual sets in the second thread suggest about 1.09 from the pawns.
It sounds like your pawns are right in range for favorable proportions. Maybe you could look at some sets whose proportions you like and use these formulae to size your own set?
Hey guys! I am making a chess board and pieces custom for my boyfriend as a present. Being very new to chess I am kind of in over my head with this project. I want to make the size of each pieces correctly but it’s confusing. If anyone could help that would be great!
my board has tiles that are 2x2 inch and I have looked at the forums and had made my pawns with a 1.13 inch base.
Any help would be hugely appreciated