A very tactical opening against 1.e4?

Sort:
KefkaKGA

I currently use the French Defense, but I find myself not doing too good with it at times and the cramped position is sometimes really annoying. Don't get me wrong, I like to use it and I've had some good games with it, but I'm just wondering if I should stick with it or use a different opening instead.

If I should change, which opening should I use?(And please don't tell me to use the Sicilian...)

If I should stick with it, what are good ways to deal with White's bishops constantly pinning my Knights and how should I deal with my Light-squared Bishop?

Shadowsoftime99

Here's my best opening as black after 1.e4:

bigryoung

alekhine's defense leads to a lot of piece play but it takes a bit of getting used to

bigryoung

if it transposes to the vienna that is also a sharp opening

browni3141
pfren wrote:

1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bc4 Nd4? 4.Nxd4 exd4 5.c3 and White is already clearly better.

Other than that it's a great opening... 


 Agreed. I played a thematic tourney starting with 3. ... Nd4 and white has a large advantage that is easily felt. It is very hard to play with black and if white is a decent player and takes more than a few seconds considering the position he will not take the pawn.

Gil-Gandel

Agreed, the "Blackburne Shilling Gambit" is a spectacular trap but not really sound. Laughing

UnratedGamesOnly
KefkaKGA wrote:

I currently use the French Defense, but I find myself not doing too good with it at times and the cramped position is sometimes really annoying. Don't get me wrong, I like to use it and I've had some good games with it, but I'm just wondering if I should stick with it or use a different opening instead.

If I should change, which opening should I use?(And please don't tell me to use the Sicilian...)

If I should stick with it, what are good ways to deal with White's bishops constantly pinning my Knights and how should I deal with my Light-squared Bishop?


 I use and have very good results with the French for the exact reason you want to get away form it.  It works wonders against impatient tactical players. 

KefkaKGA
UnratedGamesOnly wrote:
KefkaKGA wrote:

I currently use the French Defense, but I find myself not doing too good with it at times and the cramped position is sometimes really annoying. Don't get me wrong, I like to use it and I've had some good games with it, but I'm just wondering if I should stick with it or use a different opening instead.

If I should change, which opening should I use?(And please don't tell me to use the Sicilian...)

If I should stick with it, what are good ways to deal with White's bishops constantly pinning my Knights and how should I deal with my Light-squared Bishop?


 I use and have very good results with the French for the exact reason you want to get away form it.  It works wonders against impatient tactical players. 


lol, well it's not that I want to get away from it, it's that I'm wondering if I should stick with it :p

 

Anyway, the impatient players DO make the French Defense really fun to use. I guess I'll keep using it and see if I get better results.

BlueKnightShade

A very tactical opening against 1.e4?

What about attacking the pawn right from the first move:

1. e4 d5   (Scandinavian Defense)

or

1. e4 Nf6   (Alekhine's Defence)

Gm_andrewfeng
Gil-Gandel
Scarlet_chessmaster wrote:

...Your point?

tigergutt

1...e5 is alot more tactical than people give it credit for and positions isnt that cramped

MAttos_12

Center counter gambit can be fun, if probably not very good at higher levels.

 

browni3141
pfren wrote:

The French is a fine opening. Just see how the great players were handling the Black men: Botvinnik, Petrosian, Korchnoi, Uhlmann.

The "bad" white squared bishop is part of the overall positional trade of the opening, and can be handled in various ways.

Another idea is playing 1...e5. There the only worry is the Ruy Lopez, but even there Black can play sharply AND soundly- say what Shirov has named the "Tkachiev Variation": 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.Bb5 a6 4.Ba4 Nf6 5.0-0 b5 6.Bb3 Bc5.


I love playing that variation. I almost always play Bb7 later which transposes into the Archangelsk variation I think.

AJF93

Here is another vote for the Alekhine defence.  I use it all the time.  But you have start trading pieces to get some room.

Shadowsoftime99

To anyone who insulted my precious Blackburne Gambit:

Any other tries to refute?
Shadowsoftime99

Could you post an example of why that would be even marginally good for white?

waffllemaster
tjchessmaster wrote:

Could you post an example of why that would be even marginally good for white?


Black loses a pawn and the right to castle.  The tactical point being that if black takes on f7 with the king then Qh5+ regains the piece with advantage to white.

Shadowsoftime99

Hmm... interesting... Ok, you got me there!

Wrinn

 

 

That's what happens.