1. e4 is a stronger opening for those who like to attack and play actively. 1. d4 is a stronger opening for those who like to close up the middle and wait for the other player to make a mistake.
At your level, blunders still abound, so it's not too surprising to see 1. d4 played a lot. I'd recommend 1. ..e6 or 1. ..Nf6 in reply, rather than the symmetrical 1. ..d5.
I am currently in the low 700s, and it seems that every game I play as black, my opponent opens with d4. Is there a reason this opening is used so much, at least for that rating? I've been led to believe that e4 with the King's Pawn was the most popular/fundamental opening move.