Nf6 or d5?

Sort:
14MJFOWLER68

Hi there!which is better against d4?d5 or Nf6...what do you guys play?

Scottrf

Play d5 until you don't have to ask the question.

blueemu

As far as "which move is best?", the two moves are about equal in worth. Play the one that you feel more comfortable with.

I'm more comfortable with Nf6, so I play that.

14MJFOWLER68

is d5 more solid for black?

14MJFOWLER68

what is he ultimate difference between the 2?

blueemu

1. ... d5 is solid and tries to meet White's opening head-on. Because it is a symmetrical line, it limits White to a small advantage; but makes it very likely that he will get that small advantage.

1. ... Nf6 is assymetrical and unbalancing, and offers both White and Black more play, and more chances to go wrong. Bigger risk, but bigger potential reward.

I prefer unbalanced positions, especially as Black.

14MJFOWLER68

I used to play Nf6...loved it but now im not so sure about it...Is the modern Benoni defence bad for black...?

cognismantis

From what I gather, the modern benoni is risky and lost popularity due to the taimonov

14MJFOWLER68

Taimanov?dont think ive ever seen the variation

cognismantis

It is the one where white pushes f4. 

14MJFOWLER68

oh and got pawns on d5,e4 and f4?that really cramps black

cognismantis

If you like to play imbalanced positions like the benoni and nf6, why not the dutch.

14MJFOWLER68

Mikhail Tal also played it if i am not mistaken?

14MJFOWLER68

I have thought about the Dutch countless times...somehow f5 scares me haha

SocialPanda

you can use Nf6 to try to avoid some exchange variations against the QGD if you plan to continue with d5 later anyway.

Scottrf
cognismantis wrote:

If you like to play imbalanced positions like the benoni and nf6, why not the dutch.

Nf6 isn't necessarily unbalanced anyway.

SocialPanda
14MJFOWLER68
socialista wrote:
 

that just transposes into the QGD?

14MJFOWLER68

would the main line kings indian defence be better than the modern benoni in any way?

SocialPanda
14MJFOWLER68 wrote:
socialista wrote:
 

that just transposes into the QGD?

Exactly.