The Turk!

Sort:
Dark-rai

Anybody else remember reading about this amazing machine? Granted it was operated via another human player and had no real AI, it was still a fantastic design (mechanically) and a precursor to the actual chess computers we have today. Interesting as well to note that quetions regarding the capacities of artificial intelligence were in question back in the 1700s.

http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/object-of-intrigue-the-turk?utm_source=facebook.com&utm_medium=atlas-page

Dark-rai

Wow, that comment was absurdly ignorant. I mean that last sentence is just flat-out wrong reducto ad absurdum.

 

There were plenty of machines around back then that led people to contemplate the possibilities of artificial intelligence - there are many ponderous essays I've read from around that period theorizing such machines. Intelligence isn't something that can be accurately measured, that seems to be a divisive argument but that's where I stand on it. However, you can clearly define that which is intelligent and that which is not. Unless that rock is sentient, it isn't intelligent. It's just a solid mineral... I hope for your sake you were trolling.

Dark-rai

They're composed of matter as is everything but they cannot think. I know what argument you're attempting to make, and I respect that you're trying to rationalize such an irrational thought, but it just doesn't work at all. Intelligence is defined by the ability to acquire and use knowledge and skills. Can a rock do this?

Dark-rai

Lmao that was a good one, cheers :P

Ziryab

Read this book the year it came out or perhaps the following year. Http://www.amazon.com/The-Turk-Eighteenth-Century-Chess-Playing-Machine/dp/B000HWZ28Q

Twenty-five years ago, I read short fiction by Edgar Allan Poe and by Ambrose Bierce that dealt with chess playing machines. Poe also wrote a work of nonfiction concerning the Turk, as I recall.

Dark-rai

Yeah Poe's writings on it were very, very detailed. Like, ridiculously so. Read a little bit of it myself

Dark-rai

lol do you seriously believe your own bullshit? Does anybody who's following this thread subscribe to such pretentious arguments? A rock isn't fooling anybody, it lacks the capacity to think... the brain is composed of particles but is much more than you make it sound - I mean we definitely have intent and desire. For example, you've intended to try to sell me a crock of shit in this thread, either for your own personal amusement because you're a troll or you really are just that pretentious

Dark-rai

Also a 'factoid' is unverified or false or spurious, but which is presented to appear as a true fact. What you applied it to makes sense, but just saying, you arbitrarily throw around words you clearly don't know.

Dark-rai

The forces that cause the rock to move are gravity you fucking halfwit lol. That is no correlation to intelligence. Man you MUST be trolling. Either way, not responding to you from here on out.

bigpoison

Wow! What's an inanimate object, George?

Dark-rai

Can people be reported on here for stupidity?

Ziryab

If I kick a rock, gravity does not cause it to move, but it does play its part in ceasing the movement.

Dark-rai

It most certainly does play a role in making it move. There are other factors like velocity and trajectory etc., but gravity determines how easily it moves.

Dark-rai

It most certainly does play a role in making it move. There are other factors like velocity and trajectory etc., but gravity determines how easily it moves.

Dark-rai
[COMMENT DELETED]
Ziryab

[Double post COMMENT DELETED]

Ziryab

The force of one body acting on another body moves the rock. That's sorta what fiveofswords was getting at with:

Fiveofswords 

sentience suggests awareness. A rock might seem to be aware of when you kick it and it reponds by running away. before you consider this to be absurd you should remember that the fundamental forces causing the rock to move are the exact same fundamental forces causing the particles in your brain to move. its actually no different whatsoever. You are incapable of understanding this because, perhaps, you simply lack the synapses. Well i cant instruct a rock.

-----------------

Gravity provides resistance that slows and ultimately stops the movement. Gravity also facilitates the gait that led up to the kick, but that is a secondary factor in terms of the movement of the rock.

Velocity and trajectory are measures of its movement, not forces causing it to move.

batgirl

HERE is source material for the Turk, Ajeeb and Mephisto, all automatons.

Ziryab
Fiveofswords wrote:

it is quite possible to kick a rock in space you know. and its also possible for the rock to collide with another object to halt its movement. without any gravity.

True. Gravity is not always the cause of it stopping. Moreover, if I kick it off a cliff, gravity will be the principal cause of its movement.

Ordinarily, when I kick a rock down the road where I am walking my boxers, the basic physics are as I described.

 

Ziryab
Fiveofswords wrote:
Ziryab wrote:
Fiveofswords wrote:

it is quite possible to kick a rock in space you know. and its also possible for the rock to collide with another object to halt its movement. without any gravity.

True. Gravity is not always the cause of it stopping. Moreover, if I kick it off a cliff, gravity will be the principal cause of its movement.

Ordinarily, when I kick a rock down the road where I am walking my boxers, the basic physics are as I described.

 

and the thing that stops the rock is friction. this is basically the electrical force although gravity does contribute to the rocks increasing its friction on the surface of the ground. many things are involved ultimately resulting in entropy being the cause of the rock stopping. the kinetic force of the rock is coverted into heat sound and other things. if anything gravity is always trying to keep the rock moving.

I think that gravity is trying to give the rock a hug. After resisting for a spell, the rock surrenders to the embrace and stops.