... i don't really like trophies. i don't know why. and i don't tend to talk chess much in chat. it's usually travel/country based (which is fun).
What if you thought of them as an extension to the chat, and came up with something insightful for the inscription?
one thing i don't like about chess.com is that after a game is finished, i don't know if a person posts anything in the chat section, like 'good game' or 'why did you make that move?' ... it'd be good to know (maybe via a flashy icon or something) if someone commented in a chess game after the game was finished.
You should get an alert on the Alert Panel if someone has written extra comments after the end of the game.
My games are generally full of blunders it doesn't mean that they aren't good games. Yes some of them will be pretty terrible and not particularly good but others despite some blunders by both players will be interesting, competetive and closely contested. So to me, even though the quality of play isn't great (I'm not Kasparov) I still think that the games are good. We can always learn something from our mistakes which is a good thing also.