The Jeremy Silman (Harry Potter position)


Was too bad the last two moves wound up on the cutting room floor.
(In the movie, game ended after Bc5+)

Technically shouldn't it be gryffindor vs McGonnegall? Not Voledmort? Wasn't this McGonnegalls's puzzle?

In the movie, Ron pushes d5 starting with the Scandinavian Defense. Did Sillman create the entire game leading to this final position, or just this position?

In the movie, Ron pushes d5 starting with the Scandinavian Defense. Did Sillman create the entire game leading to this final position, or just this position?
I think it was just the positions.
But funny you should mention 1….d5. The movies producers wanted the kids to play white. And the AI as black, to capture a piece on move 1.
Well Mr Silman explained that simply wasn’t possible. The earliest he could give them a capture is move 2.
But the producers were flabbergasted. What good is hiring an IM as a technical advisor, if he doesn’t even know how to capture a piece on move one??? What were they even paying him for?
😄
(Eventually, they came around of course.)