who would be better, the best chess robot in the world or the best chess player?

Sort:
DerpTheCow
Vote for which you think pls!

(Spamming for your vote is allowed)
french

robot

Anush_Tikoo

Best chess robot

soumyakothari21

Robot 

SirikitS

Stockfish nowadays is 3800+, even.

GM_chess_player

I don't think Stockfish is 3800. He's around 3300-3400, at least, the rating estimation. 

Anyway, Stockfish would definitely crush Magnus. 

As stated before, Magnus is 2800, and Stockfish is 3300. So, Magnus < Stockfish 

SirikitS
GM_chess_player wrote:

I don't think Stockfish is 3800. He's around 3300-3400, at least, the rating estimation. 

Anyway, Stockfish would definitely crush Magnus. 

As stated before, Magnus is 2800, and Stockfish is 3300. So, Magnus < Stockfish 

Oh sorry, now i checked TCEC match and it really saying 3564 for SF; i have seen that 3800+ a few days/weeks ago there on CCC, so from there my confusion. Prolly 3564 is the right number, agree.

SirikitS

https://tcec-chess.com/

aronian22

The best robot, for sure. Magnus is at 2800 but there's no way he could beat a 3600 engine.

MSteen

This isn't even a question anymore. It's been resolved for all time. No human will ever catch up to the strongest engines. It's like asking, "Who would win a weightlifting contest--the strongest human or a forklift?"

SirikitS
MSteen wrote:

This isn't even a question anymore. It's been resolved for all time. No human will ever catch up to the strongest engines. It's like asking, "Who would win a weightlifting contest--the strongest human or a forklift?"

Chuck Norris is watching you... wink.png

duntcare

maybe magnus could crush worst chess robot? definitely not best 

zumiYstinsit
BalticSovetsky wrote:
Stockfish 12 could crush Magnus.
Magnus is 2880 or so classical
Stockfish is 3300 or so.

I'm confused as to how a rating is determined then. I thought rating was determined compared to who you play. As the distance grows the increment of increase shrinks until you get no addition for the win. Wouldn't Stockfish simply reach the improvement cap against the best player and freeze at that level? Maybe it's against other machines, but even then isn't there a max or is that not how it's calculated?

NobleElevator

Best bot obviously

now If you asked me 30 years ago I would have said Humans

but now that's just not the case.

mercatorproject

Just look at the record.

The game just is no longer the same.

2Kf21-0

bot no duh

Riggytherunky_PIM

DUDE WE ALL know the best chess bot is …………. …….……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………Martin

ebombayed_chesscareer

Stockfish has about 3500 ELO. Magnus has 2800 (or 3360 on Chess.com)

magipi

Too bad that we'll never find out what the guy meant by "chess robot".

Hripfria202

Def robot. The people can sometimes do mistakes, but not the robots