Do you think there is a relation between chess and music?

Sort:
Ben_Dubuque

Tom226 wrote:

Everyone knows that "Dun dun dun Dun!" "Dun dun dun dun"... tell me that is not straight out of a game of chess.

Then it goes "Dun dun dun dun, dun dun dun dun, dun dun dun dn" And it has this metronome sort of clock rhythm kick on here (Bum bum) , dun dun don dun , dun dun don dun, dun dun dun Dun. Bah bah bah bah bah. Bah bah bah bah bah. Bah bah bah bah , bah Buh.

Over the top of your pattern I posit a little flair

"OOOOOOOOOOOOOOEEEEEEEEEEEEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO......EEEEEEEEEEEEEEOOOOOOOOOOOOEEEEEEEEEE" note this part is in the 3 or fourth ....possibly fifth octave

Somebodysson
LuftWaffles wrote:
wasted_youth wrote:

Speaking as a professional composer (...)

Great post! Really interesting read. Can I ask what you compose?

 

 

Somebodysson wrote:

I imagine if Bach played chess he'd been an endgame virtuoso, and if Mozart played chess he'd be a top tactician. 

Uncannily accurate. As one who has studied classical music, I appreciate how the logic and clarity of Bach's music is reminiscent of a Capablanca endgame. Are you also a musician by any chance?

yep. But as a chessplayer I'm only a recent convert. But I'm hooked. 

Treskpraxis

Yes - i think there is a relationaship between chess and music... "Blitz chess is poetry in motion, its Bird Powell on Jazz piano, Charlie Parker on tennor sax. The tempo is fast & furious. But also blissfully mellodic. At times while playing Blitz chess i feel im at one with the world, flowing with its flow, in synch with its bebop rhythms"... ( Robert Desjarlais ) 

BoraPopovic

NE

Ben_Dubuque

lol 

RocknRollWoman
wasted_youth wrote:

Speaking as a professional composer who also plays (too much) chess: I think the relationship they have with one another is based solely on the shared all-importance of pattern. Any great composition, in whatever style, will make the best possible use of harmonic, melodic and formal pattern; and it's the (subconscious) appreciation of pattern which is one of the main causes of the deep sense of satisfaction you get when listening to great music (there are other elements, just as important, but they're not shared with chess).

Similarly, in chess, the ability to appreciate a brilliant game is also based on the ability to recognize the beauty of a pattern, of the way in which a player has found the best possible way to combine his pieces.

There's also the matter of dissonance (tension) and resolution of dissonance. There are many ways of buiding tension in both music and chess, but to find the perfect resolution is the mark of the true master.

The recognization and appreciation of patterns is also the foundation of mathematics, so it's no coincidence that this is the third area in which children with exceptional pattern-recognition gifts can become prodigies at a very early age.

I'd say that this importance of pattern is the only thing which all three areas have in common; you can't compare the material, but the emotional and intellectual satisfaction triggered by all three can be very similar; that's as far as it goes, but it's a lot - there's something deep in the human brain which is a central part of our makeup, and which chess, music and mathematics all manage to reach and stimulate in a similar and deeply satisfying way.

Spot on, and beautifully written.

I'm also a chess-loving musician, and the only subject i ever really enjoyed at school was mathematics.  I'd be very interested to know how many people on this site are also musicians.  And i'll bet there are plenty mathematicians here too, to crunch the numbers!

Twinchicky
Treskpraxis wrote:

Yes - i think there is a relationaship between chess and music... "Blitz chess is poetry in motion, its Bird Powell on Jazz piano, Charlie Parker on tennor sax. The tempo is fast & furious. But also blissfully mellodic. At times while playing Blitz chess i feel im at one with the world, flowing with its flow, in synch with its bebop rhythms"... ( Robert Desjarlais ) 

I definitely agree with that, as a jazz musician myself. (Although, Charlie Parker played ALTO sax, not tenor!) I think that jazz could probably be compared to chess more so than any other type of music, because when improvising a solo in a jazz group or playing chess, it all comes down to striking a balance between continuing with the development of your ideas and reacting to your opponent's/the rhythm section's.

Somebodysson

*Bud* Powell,  *Bird* aka Charlie Parker

Twinchicky
Somebodysson wrote:

*Bud* Powell,  *Bird* aka Charlie Parker

Yeah, thanks, I didn't catch that one...

PyschoPatzer

Im pretty sure Chess and Music are pretty strongly correlated. Possibly because each demands a level of competancy in almost another 'language' (either reading notes in music or understanding coordinates).  In addition, both require similar creative skill sets, chess obviously needs no explanation as once theorys over players need to think for themselves, similiar to music in terms of interpretation of playing.

Riedemann

As a musician, guitar player, teacher and chess player, i can say that absolutely YES!

Specially in terms like Material - Language, Rules/Theory, Structures, Patterns, Discipline, Strategie and Tactics (in music, when one compose a piece or practice the instrument in order to improve), Creativity, and a couple of motre etc. There are many studies also about this thema.. speacially about practicing routines of chess players and musicians..

check MY WEBSITE to see more  

Best regards

mgx9600
karatekitte wrote:

Title says it all. Or maybe chess helps with your music skills?

 

I don't think chess will help your music skills (I'm assuming you mean playing an instrument or singing). The 2 are very different, even at a fundamental level like there is no rhythm in a chess game (I'd even say speaking can help you more with music than chess).

 

WRT this post title, there are many relationships between chess and music:

- both are fun activities that make good life-long hobbies (and actually, in this regard, chess has an edge over music as musical performance is a fairly strenuous affair.

- both are great at killing time at the airport: you can easily kill off an couple of hours playing chess online or relax and listen to music for a couple of hours.

- both don't pay well as a profession. Here, I must say that music has the edge because there's more demand for music teachers; but they all pay pretty low. (Remember, only a few reach the highest levels, so as a career, we must think in terms of the masses of lowly paid teachers.)

- both are forms of entertainment that has survived the test of time and culture.  All cultures seems to have something like chess and music; some more compatible with the western standards than others. I.e. chess and msuci isn't going to go anywhere.

- both can be done on the computer with precision and ease; you can certainly ask the computer to play a musical piece for you, and the same for a chess game. You can have the computer play the accompaniment and you can have the computer play opposing moves.

Homsar
I’ve heard that chess, math and music all use the same parts of your brain when you do them.
MENGKESHI

In my experience there are some similarities - the main ones being: Thinking in lines as well as the overall position which is similar to contrupuntal lines and vertical harmony in music (and the corresponding compromises that have to be made - in music as with chess, sometimes a line seems really good on one instrumental part but doesn't work when taking everything around it into account). Also working on visualising the chessboard seems to be the visual equivalent of developing your aural memory and abilities in music. I'm mainly talking about writing linear/contrapuntal styles of music in the first point although I think it can apply to all styles to some degree... My 2p!

arshamidos6

absolutly, it help recognition, think abstraction and brain connection se site

daswurzeltier

I dont know why, but playing piano before a chess match helps definitely. Mayby because it's stimulating the brain ...

 
 

 

 

Gymstar

i think so

Chuck639

I would say chess is inclusive and more accessible to people because with music, you at least need natural talent to get further. This is my personal opinion and based on stage performance with my acoustic guitar and singing vs studying or playing chess.

Do you see stage presence and showmanship or girls flaunting for chess?

khantmyoaung

both have black and white

Solmyr1234

„Chess, like love, like music, has the power to make men happy.“---  Siegbert Tarrasch