does chess.com discriminate against russia

Sort:
MagnusCarlson202020212022
As many of you know, russias flag has been turned to a gray flag. I don’t think this is fair because it’s not really the peoples fault
Deadmanparty

You can always leave your country.

MagnusCarlson202020212022
Not that easy
marqumax
People are not punished. Their country’s image is punished. Russians are free to play on chess.com. Nothing is preventing them from doing so
MagnusCarlson202020212022
Yes, but why are they shaming the image of Russia
Deadmanparty

Russia should be shamed at the very least.

MagnusCarlson202020212022
So many people have nothing to do with the war. It’s just Putin. They are so misunderstood
MagnusCarlson202020212022
For what
MagnusCarlson202020212022
Fair, but it’s about the flags on chess.com sooo…….
Deadmanparty

The flag is a political symbol.

AutisticCath

I would say yes. Since the Russian flag has been censored. I really hate to get political but there does seem to be an inherit political bias against Russian nationals simply based on Russia itself. If the U.S. were to invade countries (and it has!), you would never see such corporate willpower to censor it. IMO, most of the censorship is based on State dollars though and that's an important distinction. It may not be chess.com desires to censor, but if the U.S. government is labelling people who don't censor the flag as "domestic terrorists" (objectively, they're not, but the U.S. government is Stalin 2.0 right now), then chess.com might face significant legal reprimands if it doesn't. Sadly.

AutisticCath
Deadmanparty wrote:

The flag is a political symbol.

A flag is not an inherently political symbol. A flag indicates where you are from. The fact that we disagree on this and yet share the same flag is proof that a national flag is inherently not a political symbol, otherwise, it would mean we would share the same political opinions.

AutisticCath
marqumax wrote:
People are not punished. Their country’s image is punished. Russians are free to play on chess.com. Nothing is preventing them from doing so

Really? Was the U.S. flag censored for Iraq? For Lebanon? For Syria? You've gotta be kidding me. Shame Russia for invading a country but the Stars and Stripes hail high and fly? I want to vomit.

AutisticCath
Deadmanparty wrote:

Russia should be shamed at the very least.

Anymore than the U.S. for it's imperialism the last three decades? If the decision of chess.com to censor the Russian flag is their private decision, they should reverse it as it is discriminatory against both Russians and Russia. If they want to shame countries for invading other countries, they should have censored the U.S. flag too. It's objectively discriminatory and your fear of Russians is inexcusable. Innocent Russians have had a genocide wrought on them because of idiots like you.

Deadmanparty
AutisticCath wrote:
Deadmanparty wrote:

The flag is a political symbol.

A flag is not an inherently political symbol. A flag indicates where you are from. The fact that we disagree on this and yet share the same flag is proof that a national flag is inherently not a political symbol, otherwise, it would mean we would share the same political opinions.

Flags represent countries run by governments.  Flags are a political symbols.

EscherehcsE
CaracticusPotts wrote:

In before the lock.

I agree, in b4 the lock, lol

explodingmacaroni
Deadmanparty wrote:

Russia should be shamed at the very least.

Of course its ok to kill a million innocent iraqis citizens in repayment for only 5000 American deaths caused by a religious group 

explodingmacaroni
Deadmanparty wrote:

Russia should be shamed at the very least.

Something tells me you been watching a little too much CNN

tlay80
AutisticCath wrote:
Deadmanparty wrote:

The flag is a political symbol.

A flag is not an inherently political symbol. A flag indicates where you are from. The fact that we disagree on this and yet share the same flag is proof that a national flag is inherently not a political symbol, otherwise, it would mean we would share the same political opinions.

You are confusing "A flag is a political symbol" with "A flag is only ever a political symbol."  The second may not be true, but the first is widely acknowledged.  It's true that flags can be used by different people in different ways -- they're not stable, univocal political signifiers.  And sure, it does have simple classificatory value in some cases.  But to pretend that a flag does not also often carry polical significance is simply to deny the way the world works.  Many institutions have therefore felt it's appropriate to hide the Russian flag on accout of Russia's actions.  You may not disagree with this decision.  Perhaps you think these institutions are being too hard on Russia, or perhaps you even think that Russia is in the right.  Those would be intellectually coherent reasons for objecting (they're reasons I would strongly disagree with, but that's beside the point). But to pretend that it shouldn't be done because a flag never holds political meaning is risible.

explodingmacaroni

Mods will be here any minute 

This forum topic has been locked