Anyway, the basic structure of the argument is "a species that has developed civilization has the requisite tools to create a game like chess. Therefore chess existed as soon as civilizations did."
Which is of course nonsense.
um not quite.
i said something more along the lines of
chess is loosely based on certain facets of evolved society
the facets being
facet 1: the ability to think logically
facet 2: warfare
etc etc
so obviously chess must have appeared AFTER those facets appeared in the chain of evolution
(for instance chess wasnt invented around the time when mankind was a primate, for LOGIC of the sort you see in chess, didnt exist then
No doubt you'll say apes have logic, too but their logic isnt as advanced as chess logic
Chess, checkers, kickboxing, swimming, the world has no end of ancient sports.
But is chess the most ancient?
To figure the answer out, one must consider the history of human evolution, and compare it with the complexity of chess as a game.
For instance, at what point in the human timeline did people begin to compute math?
Or Logic? Two things that form the fundementals of chess.
Also, the idea of capturing and recapturing, the idea of space, and division, subtle concepts in the game of chess.
So what doe sit all mean?
At what point in the human timeline did the human race begin to show evidence of such concepts in its own activity?
Let's break it down point by point
LOGIC: From the wheel upwards, human beings marked the birth of the evolutionary concept of logic, when they began INVENTING things. (Around 3000 BC)
Capture and recapture on the chessboard, or in effect; war The earliest human wars date back to 3000 BC, if memory serves.
Division, space...when did these things matter to humanity?
Well, as far back as humanity can remember, mankind has been about pack behaviour, which is a result of division and space.
So that is to say...the birth of the first individual civilisations, marked the concept of 'division and space' in the human timeline.
The first civilisations began in 3000 BC.
So we deduce that chess was invented in 3000 BC.