Magnus vs Kasparov with each in their prime Who would win?

I can't figure out who it better. Magnus vs Kasparov. I need your thoughts on who is better.

I would say magnus

ok thanks

Kasparov would win if Magnus was just 10 years older than now. And would have played Kasparov in the 1990s

magnus drew Kasparov when he was 10 soo he would surely beat him now too right?

well, yes, because kasparov is old now tho.

hmm that's what I thought.

Imagine prime magnus played the deep blue that played kasparov

That would be insane

i know

Probbaly Magnus but it will be a close match.

Well every newer generation has more technology and previous generation games to study from so the newer generations will always get better and better so obviously Magnus would be better

So Gukesh, Arjun, Nodirbek and other youngsters are better than Magnus, right? Just by the same logic. They're a newer generation.

The answer is: no, your statement is just obviously false, even though it might be kinda true in a very long run.