This is an intriguing question, as both Magnus Carlsen and Fabiano Caruana are among the most brilliant chess players of our time. Their skill in standard chess would certainly translate to a high level of play in the Super-Kings variant, but the dynamics of this variant would likely favour certain styles.
The Super-Kings variant fundamentally changes the game by making the king a powerful attacking piece. This dramatically alters strategic priorities, as the king is no longer a passive defender but a central combatant. Here’s how this could play out between Carlsen and Caruana:
-
Magnus Carlsen’s Edge: Magnus is renowned for his ability to adapt to unusual positions and find resources where others might struggle. His universal style and deep understanding of dynamics would likely make him a formidable player in this variant. He’s also known for his ability to handle chaos and imbalance, both of which are abundant in a variant where the king is a superpower.
-
Fabiano Caruana’s Edge: Fabiano’s incredible preparation and precision in calculated positions might give him an edge in the opening phase of the game. If he can establish a position where the super-king’s powers are controlled and integrated into a larger strategic framework, his classical approach could shine.
-
Key Factors in This Variant:
- Safety vs. Activity: The "Super-King" introduces a dilemma—whether to use it as an aggressive attacker or keep it safe. Carlsen’s risk-taking and ability to intuitively balance aggression with caution might give him a slight edge.
- Tactics Over Strategy: With a super-king in play, tactical opportunities abound. This could tilt the scales slightly in Carlsen’s favour, as his tactical sharpness under pressure is legendary.
- Endgame Dynamics: The endgame in this variant would be radically different. Both players are excellent endgame technicians, but Carlsen’s creativity in unconventional situations might tip the balance.
If these two were to play a series in the Super-Kings variant, I’d expect Magnus to edge out Fabiano in a closely contested match due to his adaptability and flair for the unexpected. That said, Fabiano could absolutely hold his own and might even outperform if the games are heavily prepared.
What do you think? Would Carlsen’s dynamic style reign supreme, or would Caruana’s precise preparation carry the day?
Magnus Carlsen and Fabiano Caruana are both amazing chess players, and have done extremely well in many variants!
The Super-Kings chess variant is where the King has all the powers of a queen, and can move and capture exactly like a queen. Outside of that, the same rules of chess still apply. Jose Raul Capablanca was a genius at these types of variants. This variant been around in various forms for a long time. Some people even play it as the King can move like a queen and a knight. This fun variant has been played in different forms for quite some time now!
Who do you think would win if Magnus Carlsen played Fabiano Caruana, as both are amazing at regular chess!