Tournament Rule

Sort:
MapleDanish

Just a question for someone a little more experienced in tournaments than me (I play in them all the time but I've never directed one). 

The TD of a tournament that I'm in right now has added a rule that bugs me a bit. 

 

The tournament is a round robin that extends over several weeks.  We're about halfway through right now.  Anyways, he's sent an email out to all participants directing them to not invite spectators to the games.  Quite frankly I disagree.  If you're playing in a public place (which we usually do... although the location is by mutual agreement) you should be allowed to invite whoever you want, provided no real FIDE (or national) rules are broken.

 

Am I wrong?  Or has the Tournament Director made a mistake?

 

Ps - Adding the rule half way through the tournament is also weird in my humble opinion!

-matt

Ray_Brooks

You can bring who you like, Junior players often bring parents who hover nearby the whole game, blind players bring assistants (and dogs occasionally).

u0-0000
Ray_Brooks wrote:

You can bring who you like, Junior players often bring parents who hover nearby the whole game, blind players bring assistants (and dogs occasionally).


And does Vlad accompany you?

Moon_Cthulhu

Who sent the email?  The director of the tournament or a player?

MapleDanish
Semah wrote:

Who sent the email?  The director of the tournament or a player?


the TD

MM78

Never heard of such a ruling in years of OTB chess.  Did he/she give any reason, small venue, too much noise from previous rounds, complaints baout people getting advice etc? 

MapleDanish
MM78 wrote:

Never heard of such a ruling in years of OTB chess.  Did he/she give any reason, small venue, too much noise from previous rounds, complaints baout people getting advice etc? 


Nothing.  He said it was 'to be fair'.

Phelon

in most tournaments I have played in they didnt allow spectators. I mean they could come by but they had to wait until after the game to see me. Its not that big a deal, unless your friend was giving you moves or something that is Tongue out.

MapleDanish
Phelon wrote:

in most tournaments I have played in they didnt allow spectators. I mean they could come by but they had to wait until after the game to see me. Its not that big a deal, unless your friend was giving you moves or something that is .


Lol I would be losing a lot more if my friend was giving me moves :P ... we've already played in this tournament and I won quickly :D

magicmaster

Chess should be seen not heard....

MM78
Phelon wrote:

in most tournaments I have played in they didnt allow spectators. I mean they could come by but they had to wait until after the game to see me. Its not that big a deal, unless your friend was giving you moves or something that is .


The word spectate comes from the Latin Spectare = to watch.  So there should be no problem with anyone watching Wink or "seeing you".  You're right they shouldn't be able to talk to you until after but that's not what we're talking about i think.

MapleDanish

Yeah yeah he's just watching... talking is against the rules.