Who is better, Magnus Carlsen or Babe Ruth?

Sort:
bigpoison

I've got to go with the Babe.  Just think of the combinations he could have played if the stadiums had artificial lighting in his day!

pulix

i go with Babe too! one bat in the chess board and it's bye bye chess! :)

goldendog

and Magnus' helplessness with the curve ball.

Doggy_Style

Babe who? Is she a looker?

bigpoison

Is Magnus a southpaw?

TheGreatOogieBoogie
bigpoison wrote:

Is Magnus a southpaw?

Considering the 1/10 chance against I'm guessing not.  Besides Babe Ruth was an elite even among professionals.  Handedness doesn't even matter that much above high school varsity level anyway. 

EscherehcsE

Seeing as how the Babe is sort of motionless right now, I'd have to go with Magnus. Tongue Out

bigpoison
TheGreatOogieBoogie wrote:
bigpoison wrote:

Is Magnus a southpaw?

Considering the 1/10 chance against I'm guessing not.  Besides Babe Ruth was an elite even among professionals.  Handedness doesn't even matter that much above high school varsity level anyway. 

Forks and skewers come more naturally to southpaws.

TheGreatOogieBoogie
bigpoison wrote:
TheGreatOogieBoogie wrote:
bigpoison wrote:

Is Magnus a southpaw?

Considering the 1/10 chance against I'm guessing not.  Besides Babe Ruth was an elite even among professionals.  Handedness doesn't even matter that much above high school varsity level anyway. 

Forks and skewers come more naturally to southpaws.

But tactics and calculation are left brain activities.  Endgame and non forcing and positional sacrifices however seem more like right brain activities. 

Doggy_Style

Oh! doctors are talking, how exciting!

bigpoison
Doggy_Style wrote:

Babe who? Is she a looker?

I guess.  If you're into that kind of thing.

blueemu

Who is better... Magnus Carlsen or John Cleese?

I think everyone will agree that John Cleese is funnier.

British humor >> Norwegian humor.

Doggy_Style

Out of the wrapper and properly spread. That is so hot.

watchyourqueen

lol...just lol 

Wizard_Esk
bigpoison wrote:
Doggy_Style wrote:

Babe who? Is she a looker?

I guess.  If you're into that kind of thing.

 

The nail was bashed on the cranium.

Ubik42

babe Ruth just sat around waiting for his opponent to throw a ball.

Pre_VizsIa
EscherehcsE wrote:

Seeing as how the Babe is sort of motionless right now, I'd have to go with Magnus.

this

bigpoison

In his career, spanning the years 1914-'35, Ruth played nearly 2700 games.  All those games and nary a loss to Capablanca, Alekhine, Lasker, or Euwe. 

I don't think Carlsen would have had much of a chance.

Shivsky

I think Carlsen's ascent to pop-culture name-dropping royalty needs to be stopped. 

I nominate this man to put this boy wonder in his place:

pawnzischeme

Neither.  Don Mossi, Billy Bruton, or Doc Blanchard (while dating Liz Taylor)