Why is "theory" called theory ?

Sort:
aln67

Many people, not to say all, call "theory" the huge number of openings and their variants.

I do NOT call that a theory, it's just a great database of lines.

Would a database of thousands of English sentences be called a grammar ? No.

Which aspects of the game I call theory ? Pawn structures, weakness of light or dark squares, corresponding squares in some kinds of endings, etc, and, perhaps, some unavoidable - quasi mathematical - ending methods (Philidor Lucena etc).
halfgreek1963
aln67 wrote:

Many people, not to say all, call "theory" the huge number of openings and their variants.

I do NOT call that a theory, it's just a great database of lines.

Would a database of thousands of English sentences be called a grammar ? No.

Which aspects of the game I call theory ? Pawn structures, weakness of light or dark squares, corresponding squares in some kinds of endings, etc, and, perhaps, some unavoidable - quasi mathematical - ending methods (Philidor Lucena etc).

From Wiki: The Greek theoria (θεωρία), from which the English word "theory" (and theatre) is derived, meant "contemplation, speculation, a looking at, things looked at", from theorein (θεωρεῖν) "to consider, speculate, look at", from theoros (θεωρός) "spectator", from thea (θέα) "a view" + horan (ὁρᾶν) "to see". It expressed the state of being a spectator. Both Greek θεωρία and Latin contemplatioprimarily meant looking at things, whether with the eyes or with the mind.

briansladovich

Elementary, my dear aln67.  QED !

toiyabe
richie_and_oprah wrote:
Most people misuse the word and should use hypothosis instead when talking of an idea that may be viable but has yet to be ascertained. 

 

One of the most annoying things ever.  "Evolution is just a theory."   PUKE!!!

vfdagafdgdfagfdagafdgdaf

aln67 napisał:

Many people, not to say all, call "theory" the huge number of openings and their variants.

I do NOT call that a theory, it's just a great database of lines.

Would a database of thousands of English sentences be called a grammar ? No.

Which aspects of the game I call theory ? Pawn structures, weakness of light or dark squares, corresponding squares in some kinds of endings, etc, and, perhaps, some unavoidable - quasi mathematical - ending methods (Philidor Lucena etc).

aln67 napisał: Many people, not to say all, call "theory" the huge number of openings and their variants.I do NOT call that a theory, it's just a great database of lines.Would a database of thousands of English sentences be called a grammar ? No.Which aspects of the game I call theory ? Pawn 3 squares in some kinds of endings, etc, and, perhaps, some unavoidable - quasi mathematical - ending methods (Philidor Lucena etc). If you understand theory as philosophy of science or just science do, you're right.

vfdagafdgdfagfdagafdgdaf

Sorry I cannot use my new phone properly. It is only the last sentence from my previoys entry that matters.

aln67

@Daimonion

"If you understand theory as philosophy of science or just science do, you're right."

(also an answer to halfgreek1963, thanks for this great cultural lesson).

Well, my guess is that the meaning that everyone has in mind, *today*, when hearing the word "theory" (not the same meaning, IMHO, as speculation, hypothesis, conjecture, etc). I'm open to dialog, but I have doubts about people thinking of the original greek meaning. 

aln67
morethantwentycharac a écrit :

Something is theoretical until proven.  Are you a chess engine?

This is called a conjecture by mathematicians.

Wandle

The word has several meanings. Current usage is not confined to the specific scientific sense of a body of knowledge established by the empirical method of hypothesis, deduction and experiment.

The Greek origin is interesting and helpful, not because people use the word with that meaning today, but because it shows us the roots of today's usage. It lets us see the trajectory of the word through time.

The first meaning given by Chambers is 'an explanation or system of anything' and the next is 'an exposition of the abstract principles of a science or art'. 

In the case of chess, it means the body of knowledge which has been acquired through master practice and recorded for future use. This sense is clearly related to the scientific sense and also to the two meanings quoted from Chambers.

Another way to see it is to say that chess theory is what we can learn about the game by studying the work of others, as distinct from our own practice.

MarcoBR444

Why is "theory" called theory ?

 

In theory, if you elaborate a theory, it is theoretical action.

In theory, something you practice is practical.

Supdok

the things you call theory are known as features. then there is opening theory, endgame theory etc and "a theory" such as "pink is better than blue" or "evolution is real".

fieldsofforce

There are 2 Theories of Chess: 

1. Classical - Control the center (d4, d5, e4, e5) by occupying it with your pawns and pieces

 

2. Hypermodern - Control the center by using the power of your pawns and pieces.  The advantage of this theory is that deprives your opponent of targets to attack in the center.

There are ancillary theories concerning advantages in space, time and material.  These are acquired with superior piece development, and superior pawn structure development.

Opening Theory is based on the above stated principles.

 

toiyabe
Supdok wrote:

the things you call theory are known as features. then there is opening theory, endgame theory etc and "a theory" such as "pink is better than blue" or "evolution is real".

 

How is "pink is better than blue" comparable to "evolution is real" ?  

Supdok

facepalm.

toiyabe

Are you facepalming over your own comment or what?  

Supdok

[Even abbreviating is not allowed - Mod.] is wrong with you ?

toiyabe

Your comment makes zero sense.  That's [Even abbreviating is not allowed - Mod.] is wrong with me." 

Supdok

maybe the comment wasnt meant for someone that has such a stupid problem with it.

toiyabe

Explain it then, prick.   

Wandle

Manners, please.