Your second assumption is correct. Unless specifically specified otherwise, the two top players split the 1st and 2nd place prize money ($300 in your example) and each take home $150.00.
If a trophy is involved, one of those two players would win the trophy on tie-breaks, but the cash would still be split evenly.
How are cash prizes distributed in the event of a tie for first or second?


if 1st is $100,000 and 2nd is $40,000 Then you add them togethor and split it together. 100k plus 40k is 140k dived by 2 is 70k each. This is the prize money for the millionaire chess tournament :)
Let's say if a tournament has $200 prize for 1st place and $100 prize for 2nd place. Two person tie for first with the same score. How would a "typical" tournament give out the money? Use tie breaks and give the person with the better tie breaks $200 and the other with worse tie breaks $100? Or do they just call it a tie (without the use of tie breaks) and give each person an equal $150 split for the top 2? Or do they use a blitz playoff to break the tie instead of using tie break rules?